Files
Agent-Workbench/docs/official-first-system-audit-2026-11-06.json
T

1983 lines
75 KiB
JSON
Raw Blame History

This file contains ambiguous Unicode characters
This file contains Unicode characters that might be confused with other characters. If you think that this is intentional, you can safely ignore this warning. Use the Escape button to reveal them.
{
"schema": 1,
"kind": "official-first-complete-system-key-path-audit",
"recordedAt": "2026-11-06T14:09:15.016711+00:00",
"sourceHead": "4da2550becdf4750320cedd5ee30a7e38baba2f9",
"branch": "feat/task-agreement-1.25",
"scope": "inventory and all major-layer key-path audit, not manual line-by-line review of every file",
"production": {
"freshHealthEvidence": ".qa/official-first-system-audit-2026-11-06/formal-health-readonly.json",
"freshHealthSha256": "456fdd09327c95232c00cc054824419d06517dcf3b24312e8a7fbc5b4e6440b0",
"observedHealth": [
{
"route": "/api/health",
"status": 200,
"observedAt": "2026-11-06T13:08:18.279628+00:00",
"body": {
"app": "agent-workbench",
"version": "1.25.12",
"pid": 71628,
"ready": true,
"uptimeMs": 43891093
},
"sha256": "d7df430a07e4daf2aeea5f26d5ea77b8554f45849d90cf835df2dac2de656901"
}
],
"priorDeployedSource": "6867cd5a3094c133b09a7c50384ae844ef34c038",
"retentionScope": "prior F deployment evidence reused; health is not fresh data/credential retention verification"
},
"pendingSourceFixes": [
{
"commit": "ae5123c5",
"change": "catalog existing-model metadata refresh",
"deployed": false
},
{
"commit": "341f5f69",
"change": "diagnostic follows actual output token wire fields",
"deployed": false
},
{
"commit": "2bd7b24a",
"change": "exact official Claude capacity fallback",
"deployed": false
}
],
"thisAudit": {
"productSourceChanges": 0,
"realModelRequests": 0,
"realCredentialsRead": 0,
"productionWrites": 0,
"releaseOrRestart": false,
"publicDocumentationRequests": true,
"ownedLocalUiFixture": true,
"offlineNumberedObservations": 21,
"separateCorrections": [
"O18-C"
],
"sourceInventoryVerified": 715,
"inventory": {
"src": {
"files": 272,
"lines": 31738
},
"tests": {
"files": 171,
"lines": 20981
},
"scripts": {
"files": 272,
"lines": 24917
}
}
},
"validationBoundary": {
"offlineProbes": "21 observations and one correction; success means reproduction completed, not product correctness",
"ui": [
"owned1280 settings and persistence; owned390 actual controls/full form",
"seven prior build inputs and thirty compiled outputs verified unchanged",
"not current production Electron acceptance"
],
"priorTargetedChecks": [
"126/126 New API repairs",
"67/67 Claude capacity repair"
],
"priorFailures": "original regression/environment/network failures remain; not rerun or relabelled as pass"
},
"sourcesPath": "docs/official-first-sources-2026-11-06.json",
"sourcesSha256": "d230cfa36f12653757c9fb73d238dcbf0790d8587e3a66dffcb83765c5caaf59",
"evidenceSeal": {
"manifestPath": ".qa/official-first-system-audit-2026-11-06/MANIFEST.json",
"summaryPath": "docs/official-first-audit-evidence-2026-11-06.json",
"scope": "immutable raw audit files plus four final report/data inputs; mutable commit/push receipts kept separately"
},
"observations": [
{
"id": "O01",
"title": "Responses effort control deletes sibling summary",
"category": "defect",
"expected": {
"reasoning": {
"effort": "high",
"summary": "auto"
}
},
"observed": {
"reasoning": {
"effort": "high"
},
"text": {
"verbosity": "medium"
}
},
"evidencePath": ".qa/official-first-system-audit-2026-11-06/offline-contract-observations.json",
"evidenceSha256": "f2a8c574aabcda2a6c0e7d2290a462dd6fca8673b10ecab56d0a32dbf808b4c0"
},
{
"id": "O02",
"title": "Messages effort/mode controls delete format/display",
"category": "defect",
"expected": {
"preserve": [
"output_config.format",
"thinking.display"
]
},
"observed": {
"effortChange": {
"output_config": {
"effort": "max"
},
"thinking": {
"type": "adaptive",
"display": "summarized"
}
},
"modeChange": {
"output_config": {
"effort": "high",
"format": {
"type": "json_schema",
"schema": {
"type": "object"
}
}
},
"thinking": {
"type": "adaptive"
}
}
},
"evidencePath": ".qa/official-first-system-audit-2026-11-06/offline-contract-observations.json",
"evidenceSha256": "f2a8c574aabcda2a6c0e7d2290a462dd6fca8673b10ecab56d0a32dbf808b4c0"
},
{
"id": "O03",
"title": "Metadata-absent Opus 5.5 still offers rejected manual/disabled modes",
"category": "defect",
"expected": {
"officialModes": [
"adaptive"
],
"manualEnabled": "official 400",
"disabled": "official 400"
},
"observed": {
"offered": [
"disabled",
"enabled",
"adaptive"
],
"generated": {
"thinking": {
"type": "enabled",
"budget_tokens": 1024
}
}
},
"evidencePath": ".qa/official-first-system-audit-2026-11-06/offline-contract-observations.json",
"evidenceSha256": "f2a8c574aabcda2a6c0e7d2290a462dd6fca8673b10ecab56d0a32dbf808b4c0"
},
{
"id": "O04",
"title": "Catalog loses between_tools and empty supported-mode list falls back to all modes",
"category": "defect",
"expected": {
"sonnetModes": [
"adaptive",
"between_tools"
],
"explicitNegativeModes": []
},
"observed": {
"sonnetCatalog": {
"id": "claude-sonnet-5-5",
"name": "claude-sonnet-5-5",
"owner": "",
"lifecycle": null,
"contextLimit": 1000000,
"maxOutputTokens": 128000,
"capabilityDeclarations": {
"text": "unknown",
"tools": "unknown",
"streaming": "unknown",
"vision": "unknown",
"audio": "unknown"
},
"features": {
"thinking": "supported",
"effort": "unknown",
"pdf_input": "unknown",
"structured_outputs": "unknown",
"server_tools": "unknown",
"code_execution": "unknown",
"batch": "unknown",
"citations": "unknown",
"context_management": "unknown"
},
"efforts": [],
"modes": [
"adaptive"
],
"parameters": [],
"metadataSource": "upstream-model-list"
},
"negativeProfile": {
"id": "anthropic",
"label": "Claude Messages 兼容",
"source": "按品牌、型号与协议匹配,可手动更改",
"efforts": [
"low",
"medium",
"high",
"xhigh",
"max"
],
"modes": [
"disabled",
"enabled",
"adaptive"
],
"thinking": true
}
},
"evidencePath": ".qa/official-first-system-audit-2026-11-06/offline-contract-observations.json",
"evidenceSha256": "f2a8c574aabcda2a6c0e7d2290a462dd6fca8673b10ecab56d0a32dbf808b4c0"
},
{
"id": "O05",
"title": "Feature table says structured parameters rejected while open wire forwards them",
"category": "display_drift",
"expected": "Describe forwarding separately from structured-output validation support",
"observed": {
"row": {
"name": "结构化输出约束",
"upstream": "待确认",
"local": "尚未接入,参数保存时明确拒绝"
},
"forwarded": {
"type": "json_object"
}
},
"evidencePath": ".qa/official-first-system-audit-2026-11-06/offline-contract-observations.json",
"evidenceSha256": "f2a8c574aabcda2a6c0e7d2290a462dd6fca8673b10ecab56d0a32dbf808b4c0"
},
{
"id": "O06",
"title": "Messages block/tool cache controls are dropped; top-level control survives",
"category": "missing_adapter_capability",
"expected": "Retain official block/tool fields via an explicit native content/tool representation",
"observed": {
"system": [
{
"type": "text",
"text": "stable audit prefix"
}
],
"tools": [
{
"name": "audit_tool",
"description": "No execution",
"input_schema": {
"type": "object"
}
}
],
"topLevel": {
"type": "ephemeral"
}
},
"evidencePath": ".qa/official-first-system-audit-2026-11-06/offline-contract-observations.json",
"evidenceSha256": "f2a8c574aabcda2a6c0e7d2290a462dd6fca8673b10ecab56d0a32dbf808b4c0"
},
{
"id": "O07",
"title": "Kimi cache-write usage preserved raw but absent from normalized usage",
"category": "missing_adapter_capability",
"expected": "Normalized cache read/write/uncached fields with provider provenance",
"observed": {
"prompt_tokens": 1000,
"completion_tokens": 100,
"total_tokens": 1100,
"prompt_tokens_details": {
"cached_tokens": 600
},
"raw": {
"prompt_tokens": 1000,
"completion_tokens": 100,
"total_tokens": 1100,
"prompt_tokens_details": {
"cached_tokens": 600,
"cache_write_tokens": 300,
"uncached_tokens": 100
}
},
"protocol": "chat-completions"
},
"evidencePath": ".qa/official-first-system-audit-2026-11-06/offline-contract-observations.json",
"evidenceSha256": "f2a8c574aabcda2a6c0e7d2290a462dd6fca8673b10ecab56d0a32dbf808b4c0"
},
{
"id": "O08",
"title": "Automatic pool selects declared unsupported member in unrestricted mode",
"category": "selection_defect",
"expected": "Automatic ranking prefers capable member while explicit manual selection remains unrestricted",
"observed": {
"first": "incapable",
"requirements": [
"tools"
],
"declarations": [
{
"id": "incapable",
"tools": "unsupported"
},
{
"id": "capable",
"tools": "supported"
}
]
},
"evidencePath": ".qa/official-first-system-audit-2026-11-06/offline-contract-observations.json",
"evidenceSha256": "f2a8c574aabcda2a6c0e7d2290a462dd6fca8673b10ecab56d0a32dbf808b4c0"
},
{
"id": "O09",
"title": "Affinity is Run-scoped, not session/task-scoped",
"category": "missing_routing_capability",
"expected": "Explicit conversational affinity strategy for cross-Run continuations",
"observed": {
"runA": "incapable",
"runAAgain": "incapable",
"nextRun": "capable",
"affinityKey": "runId"
},
"evidencePath": ".qa/official-first-system-audit-2026-11-06/offline-contract-observations.json",
"evidenceSha256": "f2a8c574aabcda2a6c0e7d2290a462dd6fca8673b10ecab56d0a32dbf808b4c0"
},
{
"id": "O10",
"title": "Unlimited attempt persistence conflicts with advertised retention and lacks full ledger view",
"category": "display_and_storage_gap",
"expected": {
"actualRetention": "unlimited",
"fullLedger": "paginated"
},
"observed": {
"persisted": 1001,
"view": 100,
"advertisedRetention": 1000
},
"evidencePath": ".qa/official-first-system-audit-2026-11-06/offline-contract-observations.json",
"evidenceSha256": "f2a8c574aabcda2a6c0e7d2290a462dd6fca8673b10ecab56d0a32dbf808b4c0"
},
{
"id": "O11",
"title": "Native server-tool blocks and pause continuation not implemented",
"category": "missing_adapter_capability",
"expected": "Typed native output and continuation handling, distinct from truncated/incomplete tools",
"observed": [
{
"id": "server-tool",
"accepted": false,
"diagnostic": {
"kind": "protocol",
"source": "model_connection",
"origin": "local",
"stage": "model_request",
"title": "模型响应未通过完整性核对",
"message": "Messages 包含未接入或不完整的内容块:server_tool_use。",
"retryable": false,
"occurredAt": "2026-11-06T13:21:14.809Z"
},
"message": "Messages 包含未接入或不完整的内容块:server_tool_use。"
},
{
"id": "pause-turn",
"accepted": false,
"diagnostic": {
"kind": "protocol",
"source": "model_connection",
"origin": "local",
"stage": "model_request",
"title": "模型响应未通过完整性核对",
"message": "Messages 未完整结束或停止原因为上下文上限、暂停或未知;原响应未用于执行工具。",
"retryable": false,
"occurredAt": "2026-11-06T13:21:14.810Z"
},
"message": "Messages 未完整结束或停止原因为上下文上限、暂停或未知;原响应未用于执行工具。"
}
],
"evidencePath": ".qa/official-first-system-audit-2026-11-06/offline-contract-observations.json",
"evidenceSha256": "f2a8c574aabcda2a6c0e7d2290a462dd6fca8673b10ecab56d0a32dbf808b4c0"
},
{
"id": "O12",
"title": "Gemini-style entries parse but native nextPageToken does not",
"category": "missing_native_protocol",
"expected": "Native list/endpoint/pagination/generate/stream/auth contract",
"observed": {
"entries": [
{
"id": "models/audit-gemini",
"name": "models/audit-gemini",
"owner": "",
"lifecycle": null,
"contextLimit": 1000000,
"maxOutputTokens": 65536,
"capabilityDeclarations": {
"text": "unknown",
"tools": "unknown",
"streaming": "unknown",
"vision": "unknown",
"audio": "unknown"
},
"features": {
"thinking": "unknown",
"effort": "unknown",
"pdf_input": "unknown",
"structured_outputs": "unknown",
"server_tools": "unknown",
"code_execution": "unknown",
"batch": "unknown",
"citations": "unknown",
"context_management": "unknown"
},
"efforts": [],
"modes": [],
"parameters": [],
"metadataSource": "upstream-model-list"
}
],
"hasMore": false,
"cursor": ""
},
"evidencePath": ".qa/official-first-system-audit-2026-11-06/offline-contract-observations.json",
"evidenceSha256": "f2a8c574aabcda2a6c0e7d2290a462dd6fca8673b10ecab56d0a32dbf808b4c0"
},
{
"id": "O13",
"category": "missing_mcp_schema_support",
"title": "Ordinary union and 65-property schemas rejected regardless of open mode",
"observed": [
{
"id": "anyOf",
"accepted": false,
"message": "工具schema超出当前支持的有界JSON Schema范围。"
},
{
"id": "65-properties",
"accepted": false,
"message": "工具schema属性范围无效。"
}
],
"expected": "Support vendor/standard schemas without arbitrary work-size caps; unsupported schema must remain explicit until implemented.",
"evidencePath": ".qa/official-first-system-audit-2026-11-06/offline-harness-observations.json",
"evidenceSha256": "16ecdcefb2ea46b5f810e247a473c0a17a73a56cbaedd2b939ebff7c6c76e8e6"
},
{
"id": "O14",
"category": "remaining_hard_cap",
"title": "Open-mode MCP task still blocked after 30 operations",
"observed": "当前任务已达到30次MCP操作上限。",
"expected": "0/unlimited in unrestricted mode; keep each invocation identity and unknown outcome handling.",
"evidencePath": ".qa/official-first-system-audit-2026-11-06/offline-harness-observations.json",
"evidenceSha256": "16ecdcefb2ea46b5f810e247a473c0a17a73a56cbaedd2b939ebff7c6c76e8e6"
},
{
"id": "O15",
"category": "remaining_hard_cap",
"title": "Open-mode checkpoint still blocks after 2000 tool references",
"observed": "当前任务超过恢复包2000项工具引用的上限,请缩小任务范围。",
"expected": "Paged/streamed verified checkpoints with unlimited default, not a request to shrink the task.",
"evidencePath": ".qa/official-first-system-audit-2026-11-06/offline-harness-observations.json",
"evidenceSha256": "16ecdcefb2ea46b5f810e247a473c0a17a73a56cbaedd2b939ebff7c6c76e8e6"
},
{
"id": "O16",
"category": "instruction_drift",
"title": "MCP model-facing instruction always asks confirmation although full policy automatically approves",
"observed": {
"description": "请求用户确认后调用本次目录的已启用MCP工具。先核对固定程序/实际握手/schema,不自动重试;完整结果按工件读取。",
"fullModePolicy": {
"approve": true,
"mode": "full",
"source": "full-access-policy"
}
},
"expected": "Model-facing description derived from active approval mode; do not imply an extra manual confirmation.",
"evidencePath": ".qa/official-first-system-audit-2026-11-06/offline-harness-observations.json",
"evidenceSha256": "16ecdcefb2ea46b5f810e247a473c0a17a73a56cbaedd2b939ebff7c6c76e8e6"
},
{
"id": "O17",
"category": "silent_parameter_rewrite",
"title": "Chat streaming replaces explicit stream_options",
"expected": {
"include_usage": false,
"include_obfuscation": false
},
"observed": {
"include_usage": true
},
"evidencePath": ".qa/official-first-system-audit-2026-11-06/offline-forwarding-observations.json",
"evidenceSha256": "ef657bbe3d07c6c5a85227da29ccde24208f1fcd7e68fcf95f2706aa871c94a9"
},
{
"id": "O18",
"category": "incomplete_response_selection",
"title": "Multiple choices remain raw; harness consumes only first choice",
"observed": {
"acceptedRawChoices": 2,
"canonicalChoice": 0
},
"expected": "Explicit candidate-selection contract and complete raw retention; never apply multiple alternatives blindly.",
"sourceInference": "Provider and Chat stream choose index 0; this probe establishes acceptance, not a live stream/UI run.",
"evidencePath": ".qa/official-first-system-audit-2026-11-06/offline-forwarding-observations.json",
"evidenceSha256": "ef657bbe3d07c6c5a85227da29ccde24208f1fcd7e68fcf95f2706aa871c94a9"
},
{
"id": "O19",
"category": "cache_observation_gap",
"title": "Prompt prefix observation excludes native parameters that may affect supplier cache",
"observed": {
"schemaVersion": 2,
"method": "ordered-wire-prompt-fields-utf8",
"upstreamCache": "unknown",
"variants": [
{
"connectionId": null,
"protocol": "chat-completions",
"model": "audit-only-model",
"toolsSha256": "4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945",
"toolBytes": 2,
"toolNames": [],
"promptBytes": 100,
"previousPromptBytes": 100,
"commonPrefixBytes": 100,
"reason": "same_prompt",
"blocks": [
{
"path": "model",
"role": null,
"sha256": "bc9b64afd40848b6216a18919080b26718cc5875166afe314b32309c95e83e69",
"bytes": 18
},
{
"path": "tools",
"role": null,
"sha256": "4f53cda18c2baa0c0354bb5f9a3ecbe5ed12ab4d8e11ba873c2f11161202b945",
"bytes": 2
},
{
"path": "system",
"role": null,
"sha256": "74234e98afe7498fb5daf1f36ac2d78acc339464f950703b8c019892f982b90b",
"bytes": 4
},
{
"path": "messages[0]",
"role": "user",
"sha256": "684dfefce8cea4319a87556ed5340b6d2b9f530c31cc5637ea07de5524cc62bd",
"bytes": 33
}
],
"firstChange": null,
"tools": []
}
]
},
"expected": "Keep ordered prompt observation distinct from actual supplier cache; add a vendor-specific cache-relevant parameter fingerprint.",
"evidencePath": ".qa/official-first-system-audit-2026-11-06/offline-forwarding-observations.json",
"evidenceSha256": "ef657bbe3d07c6c5a85227da29ccde24208f1fcd7e68fcf95f2706aa871c94a9"
},
{
"id": "O18-C",
"corrects": "O18.sourceInference",
"kind": "correction",
"originalEvidence": "offline-forwarding-observations.json",
"originalPreserved": true,
"finding": "Nonstreaming accepts multiple raw choices and Provider consumes choices[0]; Chat streaming rejects every choice.index other than 0 locally.",
"observed": {
"streamedSecondChoiceRejected": true,
"diagnostic": "当前只接入单个Chat候选流。",
"streamTerminal": false,
"capturedBytes": 247
},
"limitation": "Synthetic in-memory SSE; no live supplier, HTTP request, UI assertion, or alternative execution.",
"evidencePath": ".qa/official-first-system-audit-2026-11-06/offline-correction-observations.json",
"evidenceSha256": "8fd84fb828a72e1ca145d33b908e2e090467dce744dabf2a21d6a14f8a2669a7"
},
{
"id": "O20",
"category": "policy_display_drift",
"title": "Identity policy says require-match while unrestricted execution records and continues",
"observed": {
"configuredPolicy": "require-match",
"executionMode": "unrestricted",
"reportedIdentity": "mismatch",
"requestStatus": "completed",
"consumptionOutcome": "completed",
"mockFetchCalls": 1
},
"sourceInterpretation": "ModelIdentityDetails displays pause for require-match regardless of executionMode; production UI was not changed or exercised by this probe.",
"expected": "Expose requested and effective policy accurately, and preserve the unrestricted default; do not reintroduce compulsory identity interception.",
"evidencePath": ".qa/official-first-system-audit-2026-11-06/offline-correction-observations.json",
"evidenceSha256": "8fd84fb828a72e1ca145d33b908e2e090467dce744dabf2a21d6a14f8a2669a7"
},
{
"id": "O21",
"category": "fixed-load-count-cap",
"title": "Saved-credential metadata with 102 entries is marked unavailable even in unrestricted mode",
"observed": [
{
"entries": 101,
"blocked": false,
"loadedEntries": 101,
"originalMetaEntries": 101
},
{
"entries": 102,
"blocked": true,
"loadedEntries": 0,
"originalMetaEntries": 102
}
],
"limitation": "Only synthetic metadata count gate; no encryption/decryption, valid saved payload restore, real Key or real vault read; original meta is not deleted.",
"expected": "Saved-credential metadata should load by supported version and record validity, not a fixed connection-count cap.",
"evidencePath": ".qa/official-first-system-audit-2026-11-06/offline-credential-scope-observations.json",
"evidenceSha256": "fb9cba4aaadf9ab1bb4cc4f143f9b9ecf32cff0636a2c9aa78e786f92fd0cec1"
}
],
"capabilities": [
{
"id": "C01",
"name": "模型发现、多连接、多模型池",
"implementation": "implemented-partial",
"validation": "local-and-recorded-live",
"deployment": "1.25.12; refresh repair source-only",
"issues": [
"I04",
"I13",
"I15",
"I29"
]
},
{
"id": "C02",
"name": "原生参数与推理选择",
"implementation": "implemented-with-defects",
"validation": "offline-and-owned-web-observed",
"deployment": "1.25.12; current controls still defective",
"issues": [
"I01",
"I02",
"I03",
"I08"
]
},
{
"id": "C03",
"name": "官方容量、默认本地透传",
"implementation": "implemented-partial",
"validation": "67 prior targeted plus current audit",
"deployment": "passthrough deployed; official fallback source-only",
"issues": [
"I29"
]
},
{
"id": "C04",
"name": "官方认证/版本/云平台",
"implementation": "implemented-bearer-and-x-api-key-only",
"validation": "local-contract-not-global-live",
"deployment": "1.25.12 for current subset",
"issues": [
"I14",
"I16",
"I17"
]
},
{
"id": "C05",
"name": "JSON/SSE、原错与unknown用量",
"implementation": "implemented-with-coverage-gaps",
"validation": "historical-live-and-current-offline",
"deployment": "1.25.12; wire diagnostic repair source-only",
"issues": [
"I02",
"I10",
"I18",
"I21",
"I28",
"I29"
]
},
{
"id": "C06",
"name": "ask/auto/full持久权限与开放执行",
"implementation": "implemented-with-residual-caps",
"validation": "historical-runtime-and-current-offline",
"deployment": "1.25.12",
"issues": [
"I05",
"I06",
"I07",
"I08",
"I33"
]
},
{
"id": "C07",
"name": "型号声明/响应身份记录",
"implementation": "implemented-not-weight-authentication",
"validation": "historical-live-and-current-mock",
"deployment": "1.25.12",
"issues": [
"I08"
]
},
{
"id": "C08",
"name": "自动适配与会话连续性",
"implementation": "implemented-run-routing-only",
"validation": "offline-observed",
"deployment": "1.25.12",
"issues": [
"I04",
"I11",
"I15"
]
},
{
"id": "C09",
"name": "原生多模态/文件",
"implementation": "basic-png-image-only",
"validation": "prior-owned-vision-ui",
"deployment": "1.25.12 for basic image",
"issues": [
"I20"
]
},
{
"id": "C10",
"name": "原生服务端工具/续接/候选/后台",
"implementation": "not-implemented-completely",
"validation": "rejection-observed-and-source",
"deployment": "not deployed as workflow",
"issues": [
"I18",
"I19",
"I21",
"I37"
]
},
{
"id": "C11",
"name": "文件读写/改动集/自动应用/Git回滚",
"implementation": "implemented",
"validation": "historical-Node-React-Python-delivery-and-local-QA",
"deployment": "1.25.12",
"issues": []
},
{
"id": "C12",
"name": "环境诊断/依赖/Node/Python检查",
"implementation": "implemented",
"validation": "AH/local-and-historical-AD-AE",
"deployment": "1.25.12 including AH/AI",
"issues": []
},
{
"id": "C13",
"name": "命令执行/完整日志/停止/Git证据",
"implementation": "implemented-pipes",
"validation": "AI/local-and-historical-live",
"deployment": "1.25.12",
"issues": [
"I22"
]
},
{
"id": "C14",
"name": "要求证据/单轮观察/终态报告",
"implementation": "implemented",
"validation": "historical-A-B-AI-QA",
"deployment": "1.25.12",
"issues": [
"I24",
"I35"
]
},
{
"id": "C15",
"name": "工具目录/原请求前缀/重复读取观察",
"implementation": "implemented-observation-not-benefit",
"validation": "historical-C-D-and-current-offline",
"deployment": "1.25.12",
"issues": [
"I12",
"I35"
]
},
{
"id": "C16",
"name": "缓存控制/归一统计/会话缓存",
"implementation": "implemented-partial",
"validation": "one-live-cache-observation-and-offline",
"deployment": "1.25.12 subset",
"issues": [
"I09",
"I10",
"I11",
"I12",
"I35"
]
},
{
"id": "C17",
"name": "可关闭提醒与实际回读",
"implementation": "implemented-default-off",
"validation": "D-owned-HTTP-web-desktop-release",
"deployment": "1.25.10 onward",
"issues": [
"I35"
]
},
{
"id": "C18",
"name": "来源经验草稿/采用撤销/完整修订",
"implementation": "implemented-semantic-benefit-unknown",
"validation": "E-owned-and-release-QA",
"deployment": "1.25.11 onward",
"issues": [
"I35"
]
},
{
"id": "C19",
"name": "Worker角色/模型绑定/真实质量回收",
"implementation": "implemented-partial",
"validation": "F-owned-and-release-QA",
"deployment": "1.25.12",
"issues": [
"I24",
"I25",
"I35"
]
},
{
"id": "C20",
"name": "Skills/MCP生态",
"implementation": "implemented-local-subset",
"validation": "historical-QA-and-current-offline",
"deployment": "1.25.12",
"issues": [
"I05",
"I06",
"I08",
"I25"
]
},
{
"id": "C21",
"name": "内置浏览器/页面预览/DOM动作",
"implementation": "implemented-fixed-action-set",
"validation": "historical-web-desktop-and-current-owned-form",
"deployment": "1.25.12",
"issues": [
"I23"
]
},
{
"id": "C22",
"name": "Windows桌面桥/本机加密凭据",
"implementation": "implemented-not-general-OS-control",
"validation": "historical-DPAPI-and-install-QA-not-real-key-read",
"deployment": "1.25.12",
"issues": [
"I23",
"I38"
]
},
{
"id": "C23",
"name": "DeepSeek Harness/外部完整引擎",
"implementation": "DeepSeek-bridge-implemented-others-missing",
"validation": "fixed-SDK-owned-and-historical-live",
"deployment": "1.25.12 bridge; full Codex/Claude Code not implemented",
"issues": []
},
{
"id": "C24",
"name": "原版Purge加载与对照",
"implementation": "mechanism-implemented-benefit-unknown",
"validation": "historical-AG-four-groups-not-comparable",
"deployment": "1.25.12 default-off option",
"issues": [
"I36"
]
},
{
"id": "C25",
"name": "REA来源分析与证据工件",
"implementation": "implemented-static-job-adapter",
"validation": "historical-source-and-owned-QA",
"deployment": "1.25.12",
"issues": []
},
{
"id": "C26",
"name": "Companion手机查看/批准/停止",
"implementation": "implemented-real-current-device-unverified",
"validation": "historical-owned-contracts",
"deployment": "1.25.12",
"issues": [
"I32",
"I33"
]
},
{
"id": "C27",
"name": "Mnemo及跨产品协作",
"implementation": "read-only-contract-feedback-only",
"validation": "synthetic-original-package-review",
"deployment": "native export/inbound delegation missing",
"issues": [
"I31"
]
},
{
"id": "C28",
"name": "SQLite事件/工件/恢复检查点",
"implementation": "implemented-with-caps-and-scale-risk",
"validation": "historical-recovery-and-current-offline/source",
"deployment": "1.25.12",
"issues": [
"I07",
"I13",
"I26"
]
},
{
"id": "C29",
"name": "源码打包/独立程序/安装回退",
"implementation": "implemented-source-data-separated",
"validation": "historical-F-release-and-retention",
"deployment": "1.25.12; three later source repairs pending",
"issues": [
"I27",
"I28",
"I29"
]
},
{
"id": "C30",
"name": "Orven三配色/任务与模型中心界面",
"implementation": "implemented-with-copy-and-controls-drift",
"validation": "historical-release plus owned1280/390",
"deployment": "1.25.12 for brand; no new production UI audit",
"issues": [
"I03",
"I08",
"I30"
]
}
],
"issues": [
{
"id": "I01",
"title": "推理快捷编辑丢失嵌套原生字段",
"priority": "P0",
"statusAtAudit": "confirmed-defect",
"impact": "修改 effort 或 thinking 会删除 summary、output_config.format、thinking.display,用户请求未如实保留。",
"nextChange": "只修改目标键;删除目标值也不删除同对象其他字段;明确默认重置的范围。",
"acceptance": "三协议往返、JSON/快捷控件/保存/重新打开,非目标字段逐项保持。",
"observations": [
"O01",
"O02"
],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/shared/contracts/model-parameter-profiles.mjs",
"line": 54,
"sha256": "1264a90ba612b721ea639206cd6d8f595309c7bda38f80c45bb13c78af4a2d1f",
"match": " else next[effortField] = effortField === 'reasoning_effort' ? effort : { effort };"
},
{
"path": "src/shared/contracts/model-parameter-profiles.mjs",
"line": 57,
"sha256": "1264a90ba612b721ea639206cd6d8f595309c7bda38f80c45bb13c78af4a2d1f",
"match": " else if (field === 'budget') next.thinking = { type: 'enabled', budget_tokens: value };"
}
],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I02",
"title": "Chat 流式覆盖用户 stream_options",
"priority": "P0",
"statusAtAudit": "confirmed-defect",
"impact": "include_usage=false 与其他上游 stream_options 被整对象替换。",
"nextChange": "透传显式原生设置;默认建议与用户值分开,不隐式覆盖。",
"acceptance": "实际本机 HTTP wire 与用户对象一致,缺失字段才按明确策略补充。",
"observations": [
"O17"
],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/shared/contracts/model-request.mjs",
"line": 22,
"sha256": "5606dc2c245e3461c35613773c0d1b47718acd28a6fe4abd07406bbe80af2e11",
"match": " ...(stream ? { stream_options: { include_usage: true } } : {}) };"
}
],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I03",
"title": "Claude 型号推理能力与官方未对齐",
"priority": "P0",
"statusAtAudit": "confirmed-defect",
"impact": "Opus5.5 仍能生成官方拒绝的 enabled/disabled;between_tools 未解析;全否定目录又回退全部选项。",
"nextChange": "以精确型号、协议、官方版本解析模式/effort/条件,区分未知与明确不支持。",
"acceptance": "官方新旧型号矩阵、目录全否定和缺失情况通过;UI/保存/wire 一致;兼容显式覆盖仍可用。",
"observations": [
"O03",
"O04"
],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/shared/contracts/model-catalog.mjs",
"line": 38,
"sha256": "abb7b41982d072ecdb8c8d7c2feb67228eeb03c751c3f10b8557ac12b25022e1",
"match": " const modes = ['disabled', 'enabled', 'adaptive'].filter(value => supported(caps.thinking?.types?.[value]) === 'supported');"
},
{
"path": "src/shared/contracts/model-parameter-profiles.mjs",
"line": 27,
"sha256": "1264a90ba612b721ea639206cd6d8f595309c7bda38f80c45bb13c78af4a2d1f",
"match": " modes: metadata?.features?.thinking === 'unsupported' ? [] : metadata?.modes?.length ? metadata.modes : ['disabled', 'enabled', ...(protocol === 'anthropic-messages' ? ['adaptive'] : [])],"
}
],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I04",
"title": "自动模型池可选明确不支持工具的成员",
"priority": "P0",
"statusAtAudit": "confirmed-selection-defect",
"impact": "需要工程工具时,自动模式仍可把请求发给明确不支持工具的模型。",
"nextChange": "自动候选按能力与任务排序,显式手选/强制尝试与自动适配分别记录,不恢复全局拒发。",
"acceptance": "自动选择工具支持成员;未知有明确策略;用户手选仍可透传;记录选择依据。",
"observations": [
"O08"
],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/core/models/model-hub.mjs",
"line": 321,
"sha256": "630c276a445641e3abaf920957e01d6ffd1b50f8264c0227ee55d29073d9dbb9",
"match": " const eligible = routing.members.filter(value => unrestricted(this.store) || capabilityRejections(value, requirements, value.credentialRevision).length === 0);"
}
],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I05",
"title": "开放模式仍有每任务 30 次 MCP 操作上限",
"priority": "P0",
"statusAtAudit": "confirmed-execution-cap",
"impact": "长工程在已有开放权限下仍被固定次数挡住。",
"nextChange": "移除开放模式次数门槛,完整账本用游标/分页;保留每次真实身份、结果和停止。",
"acceptance": "同任务第31次及更长序列可执行且无旧记录丢失;停止/重启 unknown 保留。",
"observations": [
"O14"
],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/core/tools/mcp-registry.mjs",
"line": 121,
"sha256": "6e91279f20aa08850478f29155702f6f6b41d576ea7d58204d84a66d7b4ec360",
"match": " if (this.jobs(session).filter(job => job.taskId === session.taskId).length >= 30) throw mcpError('当前任务已达到30次MCP操作上限。');"
}
],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I06",
"title": "MCP JSON Schema 子集拒绝常见合法工具",
"priority": "P0",
"statusAtAudit": "confirmed-adapter-gap",
"impact": "anyOf 和65属性等普通 schema 无法接入,与开放工具能力目标不符。",
"nextChange": "支持官方/服务器声明的 JSON Schema 或按协议原样转交;不用固定属性数假冒模型能力。",
"acceptance": "union/ref/嵌套/65以上属性工具真实握手后可选择;错误与原 schema 可核对。",
"observations": [
"O13"
],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/core/tools/mcp-contract.mjs",
"line": 24,
"sha256": "9f534148fcbf1e6c016b9b6da70d9af2046ffa910dc4710b8a085c90c8c99dab",
"match": " if (!plain(value) || ++nodes > 256 || depth > 8 || Object.keys(value).some(key => !keywords.has(key))) throw mcpError('工具schema超出当前支持的有界JSON Schema范围。', 400);"
}
],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I07",
"title": "检查点仍受 30/2000/64MiB 固定上限",
"priority": "P0",
"statusAtAudit": "confirmed-execution-cap",
"impact": "工具引用2000项、检查点30个或结果64MiB可阻断开放工程恢复。",
"nextChange": "采用分段索引、流式校验与分页恢复,去掉开放模式固定额度。",
"acceptance": "跨各旧边界建立和恢复检查点,旧工具/结果原 SHA 与归属完整。",
"observations": [
"O15"
],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/core/tasks/task-checkpoint-manager.mjs",
"line": 15,
"sha256": "2f50f9de2e6b8c90376028ed2814eb795633e1ea917ab944a977299220ad820f",
"match": "export const TASK_CHECKPOINT_LIMITS = Object.freeze({ checkpoints: 30, tools: 2000, resultBytes: 64 * 1024 * 1024 });"
}
],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I08",
"title": "能力/权限说明与实际行为不一致",
"priority": "P1",
"statusAtAudit": "confirmed-display-drift",
"impact": "结构化参数被说成拒绝、MCP仍提示确认、require-match显示暂停但开放模式继续。",
"nextChange": "展示声明能力、本地实现、实际权限/身份策略与可选覆盖;同步模型提示。",
"acceptance": "ask/auto/full 与完整参数/身份原件在网页和桌面一致;不恢复强制拦截。",
"observations": [
"O05",
"O16",
"O20"
],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/shared/contracts/model-parameter-profiles.mjs",
"line": 81,
"sha256": "1264a90ba612b721ea639206cd6d8f595309c7bda38f80c45bb13c78af4a2d1f",
"match": " { name: '结构化输出约束', upstream: states[connection.upstreamModel?.features?.structured_outputs ?? 'unknown'], local: '尚未接入,参数保存时明确拒绝' },"
},
{
"path": "src/core/tools/mcp-contract.mjs",
"line": 74,
"sha256": "9f534148fcbf1e6c016b9b6da70d9af2046ffa910dc4710b8a085c90c8c99dab",
"match": "export const mcpToolDefinitions = [{ type: 'function', function: { name: 'call_registered_mcp', description: '请求用户确认后调用本次目录的已启用MCP工具。先核对固定程序/实际握手/schema,不自动重试;完整结果按工件读取。',"
},
{
"path": "src/client/ModelIdentityDetails.tsx",
"line": 13,
"sha256": "3e8bd9f735e21cc62abf217fc5f184c04014ea246d45115c42a95616248ac40b",
"match": " <dt>处理方式</dt><dd>{identity?.policy === 'require-match' ? '不一致或无法核对时暂停' : '记录原结果和型号差异'}</dd>"
},
{
"path": "src/server/provider.mjs",
"line": 222,
"sha256": "9653f4318df2ed3b0570d58fda1d8cda6346dd2b6a0b016a4405360458bbc015",
"match": " if (config.executionMode === 'unrestricted' || !identity || identity.policy !== 'require-match' || modelIdentityAccepted(identity)) return;"
}
],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I09",
"title": "Messages 块/工具缓存注解丢失",
"priority": "P1",
"statusAtAudit": "confirmed-adapter-gap",
"impact": "顶层 cache_control 能透传,但系统/内容块和工具上的缓存边界被转换丢掉。",
"nextChange": "增加原生块/工具元数据保留及供应商缓存控制,按官方层级/TTL处理。",
"acceptance": "工具/系统/用户块 cache_control 经过请求与历史往返不变,缓存读写由上游 usage 证明。",
"observations": [
"O06"
],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/shared/contracts/anthropic-messages.mjs",
"line": 48,
"sha256": "ed0341d03ccffe73b1fb1fb9630ddac691a5a6ab36318a4fcc63ae689398001b",
"match": " const definitions = (tools ?? []).map(tool => {"
}
],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I10",
"title": "Kimi cache-write 未归一展示",
"priority": "P1",
"statusAtAudit": "confirmed-usage-gap",
"impact": "原 usage 还在,但归一统计缺 cache_write_tokens/uncached,不能正确比较缓存成本。",
"nextChange": "提供带供应商语义/来源的读、写、未缓存、推理 token 统计,不补造费用。",
"acceptance": "三个互斥输入类别与总量相符;流式最终用量/unknown/raw保持。",
"observations": [
"O07"
],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/core/models/protocols.mjs",
"line": 19,
"sha256": "0437d536c49d05651928a705bb6d92d5c76c6e1ce9f1a39121a6273cac873b27",
"match": " const cached = raw.cache_read_input_tokens ?? 0, created = raw.cache_creation_input_tokens ?? 0;"
}
],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I11",
"title": "亲和仅绑定 Run,缺会话缓存与状态连续性",
"priority": "P1",
"statusAtAudit": "confirmed-routing-gap",
"impact": "续接新Run可换连接/型号;跨型号历史与DeepSeek reasoning_content不能视为可无损互换。",
"nextChange": "会话/Task级可配置亲和和供应商状态绑定,用户换模显式记录影响。",
"acceptance": "同会话续接、停止恢复、失效换线、手选换模分别核对模型/历史/缓存与状态。",
"observations": [
"O09"
],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/core/models/model-hub.mjs",
"line": 326,
"sha256": "630c276a445641e3abaf920957e01d6ffd1b50f8264c0227ee55d29073d9dbb9",
"match": " const remembered = routing.sticky && this.sticky.get(runId);"
}
],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I12",
"title": "前缀观察没有供应商缓存相关参数指纹",
"priority": "P1",
"statusAtAudit": "confirmed-observation-gap",
"impact": "改effort仍显示same_prompt;这个观察不能解释供应商实际缓存命中。",
"nextChange": "保留原有序提示观察,另记录缓存相关原生参数/型号/版本/工具/TTL指纹。",
"acceptance": "参数变化单列原因;不把字节共前缀或相同指纹当缓存命中。",
"observations": [
"O19"
],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/core/context/prefix-audit.mjs",
"line": 30,
"sha256": "69f9407893c67bee6c5682666122cf6105ca347a8413e5b1122283481df0d6e2",
"match": " return { schemaVersion, method: 'ordered-wire-prompt-fields-utf8', upstreamCache: 'unknown', variants: variants(body).map(current => {"
}
],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I13",
"title": "请求账本显示100/宣称1000,无法完整分页",
"priority": "P1",
"statusAtAudit": "confirmed-observability-gap",
"impact": "开放模式已保存1001以上尝试,但视图仅100且宣称保留1000,历史难核查。",
"nextChange": "完整游标检索/导出和准确保存说明;逐请求存储替代整数组回写。",
"acceptance": "所有历史尝试可分页/导出且归属、usage、unknown、raw SHA不变。",
"observations": [
"O10"
],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/core/models/model-hub.mjs",
"line": 148,
"sha256": "630c276a445641e3abaf920957e01d6ffd1b50f8264c0227ee55d29073d9dbb9",
"match": " storage: { credentials: this.credentialVault ? 'memory-or-windows-user-dpapi' : 'memory', restart: '临时凭据在宿主退出后需要重新填写;已明确本机加密保存的连接按用户与原配置加载。', attemptsRetained: 1000 } }; }"
}
],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I14",
"title": "官方认证/版本/端点策略未形成完整契约",
"priority": "P1",
"statusAtAudit": "partial-implementation",
"impact": "仅Bearer/x-api-key;anthropic-version写死2023-06-01,缺版本/beta/额外头策略。旧版本失效未被证明。",
"nextChange": "供应商、传输协议、官方API版本和代理覆盖分别配置并记录实际wire。",
"acceptance": "官方示例契约与版本/beta场景可复现;自定义端点原值与原错误保持。",
"observations": [],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/server/provider.mjs",
"line": 186,
"sha256": "9653f4318df2ed3b0570d58fda1d8cda6346dd2b6a0b016a4405360458bbc015",
"match": " headers['anthropic-version'] = '2023-06-01';"
}
],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I15",
"title": "模型发现不等于完整官方能力注册表",
"priority": "P1",
"statusAtAudit": "partial-implementation",
"impact": "目录容量/功能字段不完整;OpenAI Models类型无容量,Gemini nextPageToken未识别。",
"nextChange": "自动发现+官方版本化能力表+上游声明+显式覆盖,逐字段记录来源和冲突。",
"acceptance": "多页/多型号/失效/无元数据/代理差异不覆盖用户字段;不从型号子串猜能力。",
"observations": [
"O12"
],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/shared/contracts/model-catalog.mjs",
"line": 19,
"sha256": "abb7b41982d072ecdb8c8d7c2feb67228eeb03c751c3f10b8557ac12b25022e1",
"match": "export function catalogModel(item, config = {}) {"
},
{
"path": "src/shared/contracts/model-capabilities.mjs",
"line": 1,
"sha256": "a71775c388d1afc5dfc9057528502882361694c6d9fb541e6f55257d0ca5686a",
"match": "export const MODEL_PROTOCOLS = ['chat-completions', 'responses', 'anthropic-messages'];"
}
],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I16",
"title": "缺 Gemini 原生协议",
"priority": "P1",
"statusAtAudit": "not-implemented",
"impact": "能解析类似目录不等于支持generateContent/streamGenerateContent和原生内容/思考状态。",
"nextChange": "另建官方Gemini适配器,取得可读官方schema后固定契约来源。",
"acceptance": "发现、分页、认证、流式、工具、多模态、状态、usage、原错误均有隔离与真实证据。",
"observations": [],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/shared/contracts/model-capabilities.mjs",
"line": 1,
"sha256": "a71775c388d1afc5dfc9057528502882361694c6d9fb541e6f55257d0ca5686a",
"match": "export const MODEL_PROTOCOLS = ['chat-completions', 'responses', 'anthropic-messages'];"
}
],
"dependsOn": [
"I14",
"I15"
],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I17",
"title": "缺云平台原生认证与路由",
"priority": "P1",
"statusAtAudit": "not-implemented",
"impact": "不能把Bedrock/Vertex/Foundry各种认证或部署ID当普通Bearer/v1。部分Azure兼容端点可能可用但未验。",
"nextChange": "按官方云平台分别实现身份提供器/区域/部署/签名/续期/错误,不复制存储真实Key到研究材料。",
"acceptance": "每平台固定官方契约与独立真实样本;代理转换路线单独标识。",
"observations": [],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/server/provider.mjs",
"line": 189,
"sha256": "9653f4318df2ed3b0570d58fda1d8cda6346dd2b6a0b016a4405360458bbc015",
"match": " } else if (key) headers.Authorization = 'Bearer ' + key;"
}
],
"dependsOn": [
"I14",
"I15"
],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I18",
"title": "服务端工具与官方停止/续接语义缺项",
"priority": "P1",
"statusAtAudit": "not-implemented-and-rejected",
"impact": "Claude server_tool_use/pause_turn和Responses多种服务端输出被本地协议拒绝。",
"nextChange": "原生服务端工具、结果块、签名、停止原因和继续请求独立适配,保留原响应。",
"acceptance": "官方块/SSE事件/暂停续接/usage/错误完整,不把未知块或工具结果当本地执行成功。",
"observations": [
"O11"
],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/core/models/protocols.mjs",
"line": 120,
"sha256": "0437d536c49d05651928a705bb6d92d5c76c6e1ce9f1a39121a6273cac873b27",
"match": " } else if (item.type !== 'reasoning') throw protocolFailure('Responses包含当前尚未接入的服务端工具或输出类型:' + String(item.type ?? '未标注').slice(0, 100) + '。');"
},
{
"path": "src/core/models/messages-stream.mjs",
"line": 11,
"sha256": "0631d37f3c7c4b498e7878673826d484f6ff0d8bf972d3fc266683feaa1e20b8",
"match": " consume(event) {"
}
],
"dependsOn": [
"I14",
"I15"
],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I19",
"title": "原生工具选择与用户服务端工具不可配置",
"priority": "P1",
"statusAtAudit": "not-implemented",
"impact": "tools/tool_choice为托管字段,普通原生JSON无法开启官方web/computer等能力或选择官方tool_choice。",
"nextChange": "区分工作台工具与供应商原生工具,提供明确选择和实际调用记录。",
"acceptance": "用户选择在wire准确出现;本地/远端结果归属分开;禁止盲目并行应用多个候选。",
"observations": [],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/shared/contracts/native-parameters.mjs",
"line": 10,
"sha256": "f065908247826464282ba50b34938608120c8dd740b16a74592ab342cdeb8e6b",
"match": " const managed = ['model', 'messages', 'input', 'system', 'tools', 'tool_choice', 'stream', 'apiKey', 'api_key', 'baseUrl', 'authorization', 'headers'];"
}
],
"dependsOn": [
"I18"
],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I20",
"title": "PDF/音频/视频/文件等原生内容缺项",
"priority": "P1",
"statusAtAudit": "not-implemented-beyond-basic-image",
"impact": "当前截图/PNG基本视觉不是全球模型全多模态;JPEG被转PNG,缺官方原生文件生命周期。",
"nextChange": "按供应商内容格式实现附件/原文件/媒体/引用/返回工件,不把PNG通路当所有视觉支持。",
"acceptance": "原格式/用途/上传删除/尺寸/流式输出/错误来源与真实模型验证逐项完整。",
"observations": [],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/core/context/input-attachments.mjs",
"line": 3,
"sha256": "64b84482aa71b03185813cddb1ad5c46516054e14da1d28326a0d88ee46f66d4",
"match": "import { PNG } from 'pngjs';"
}
],
"dependsOn": [
"I14",
"I15"
],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I21",
"title": "Chat 多候选非流式/流式处理不一致",
"priority": "P1",
"statusAtAudit": "confirmed-contract-gap",
"impact": "非流式留raw多choices但只消费第一个;流式非0候选本地拒绝。O18首推断已单独纠正。",
"nextChange": "定义完整保留与候选选择工作流;工程执行一次只用明确选中的完整候选。",
"acceptance": "n>1两模式原结果保持、用户/自动选择一致;不盲目执行各候选的工具。",
"observations": [
"O18",
"O18-C"
],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/core/models/model-stream.mjs",
"line": 86,
"sha256": "e354ae9fd96481c31b6f16cca89f4f7f7436449cedbdb2b879422e3c3d57d0cb",
"match": " if (choice.index !== 0) throw protocolFailure('当前只接入单个Chat候选流。');"
},
{
"path": "src/server/provider.mjs",
"line": 386,
"sha256": "9653f4318df2ed3b0570d58fda1d8cda6346dd2b6a0b016a4405360458bbc015",
"match": " const received = result.choices?.[0]?.message;"
}
],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I22",
"title": "终端缺交互PTY/输入会话",
"priority": "P1",
"statusAtAudit": "not-implemented",
"impact": "已有所属命令、完整日志/停止/Git证据,但pipes一次性输入不能替代交互终端。",
"nextChange": "增加会话PTY、stdin、resize、进程恢复与工具接口,沿用户权限直接执行。",
"acceptance": "长命令、交互输入、停止、重新附着、退出码与Git证据真实可查。",
"observations": [],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/core/owned-command.mjs",
"line": 13,
"sha256": "40113f38ef1fa629540d31753828b92792a133f7aab4b0c9253be12d568704e3",
"match": " detached: process.platform !== 'win32', stdio: [input === null ? 'ignore' : 'pipe', 'pipe', 'pipe'] });"
}
],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I23",
"title": "缺通用电脑操作能力",
"priority": "P2",
"statusAtAudit": "not-implemented",
"impact": "已有文件对话框/浏览器动作,不是任意Windows应用/全桌面computer use。",
"nextChange": "支持截图、坐标/语义动作、键盘/窗口/应用操作,与选定权限和任务归属连接。",
"acceptance": "真实多应用闭环及取消/恢复可观察;不能用本地浏览器DOM测试冒充OS控制。",
"observations": [],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/core/desktop/desktop-bridge.mjs",
"line": 9,
"sha256": "bcfc675d5448e996f8e8156146ccdbf2c122febfe8a3e338e9887afd8c826541",
"match": "export class DesktopBridge {"
}
],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I24",
"title": "Worker要求语义仍未评估",
"priority": "P1",
"statusAtAudit": "partially-implemented-benefit-unknown",
"impact": "角色/模型/成果与检查身份已绑定,但每条requirements仍为not_evaluated,不能认证角色质量。",
"nextChange": "逐要求关联实际差异/测试/观察,语义评估与确定性结果分列。",
"acceptance": "未测/失败/证据不足不通过;真实同题角色对照才证明收益。",
"observations": [],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/core/tasks/worker-evidence.mjs",
"line": 49,
"sha256": "8c077ad19a0f2391c83971ae76ac5079d110ce90fed49440fbf4139636d2a014",
"match": " requirements: [worker.goal, ...worker.assignment.requirements].map(criterion => ({ criterion, status: 'not_evaluated', source: 'sealed_assignment' })),"
}
],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I25",
"title": "Worker没有skills/MCP能力装配",
"priority": "P1",
"statusAtAudit": "confirmed-assembly-gap",
"impact": "父代理目录不能自动带给子任务,某些专业任务实际没有必要工具。",
"nextChange": "角色/子任务按需求装配继承资源、身份与作用范围,不默认要求额外审查轮。",
"acceptance": "子任务实际工具表/来源/SHA与请求相符,未装配原因显示,full流程无额外确认。",
"observations": [],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/server/runtime.mjs",
"line": 461,
"sha256": "e1b349263eac824ccbda5dda713cdce7e3567d7dbc0a3613883c5e53390030c2",
"match": " const skillCatalog = run.worker ? null : this.skillRegistry().catalog(session.projectId);"
}
],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I26",
"title": "长历史读写与响应内存规模风险",
"priority": "P2",
"statusAtAudit": "static-risk-not-benchmarked",
"impact": "启动全量加载,会话/尝试整份回写,长raw响应内存累积;未测到确定故障。",
"nextChange": "先测量,再增量事件/分页/流式工件,避免用截断历史或固定额度解决规模问题。",
"acceptance": "可复现增长曲线、RSS/时延/恢复和原字节核对;报告机器与数据规模。",
"observations": [],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/core/storage/state-database.mjs",
"line": 55,
"sha256": "2a38f7564df44c4ee5183d850064be1d46fba7e072e2b87f73afb8e1a85a1517",
"match": " writeSession(session) {"
},
{
"path": "src/core/models/model-hub.mjs",
"line": 40,
"sha256": "630c276a445641e3abaf920957e01d6ffd1b50f8264c0227ee55d29073d9dbb9",
"match": " if (recovered) this.saveAttempts();"
},
{
"path": "src/server/provider.mjs",
"line": 123,
"sha256": "9653f4318df2ed3b0570d58fda1d8cda6346dd2b6a0b016a4405360458bbc015",
"match": " const parts = []; let length = 0;"
}
],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I27",
"title": "缺仓库持续集成工作流",
"priority": "P1",
"statusAtAudit": "not-found-in-tracked-files",
"impact": "本地QA丰富但版本/适配器/包校验不能稳定由远端流水线复现。",
"nextChange": "在GitAtlas支持环境建立可重复的源码/契约/构建/安装验证任务;真实供应商另受控运行。",
"acceptance": "干净环境按锁定依赖完整执行并保留首失败/版本/source SHA;不将需浏览器/Python环境失败改绿。",
"observations": [],
"references": [],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I28",
"title": "供应商契约测试覆盖与官方更新闭环缺口",
"priority": "P1",
"statusAtAudit": "verification-gap",
"impact": "当前测试未覆盖这次发现的嵌套丢失/新推理模式/覆盖等官方契约。",
"nextChange": "官方示例/schema驱动契约夹具,版本差异/弃用更新进入能力注册表与回归。",
"acceptance": "固定来源/原字节/协议/schema/wire/真实批次相互关联;本机夹具不当真实服务验收。",
"observations": [],
"references": [
{
"path": "docs/QA-NEWAPI-COMPATIBILITY-REVIEW.md",
"sha256": "db859bfb8ce8751dda8766037b8bbf153fa7fceb6beb581bc5899ab0f8f4326d",
"evidenceKind": "reused-historical-QA-not-rerun"
},
{
"path": "docs/QA-CLAUDE-OFFICIAL-CAPACITY.md",
"sha256": "7d0c2036a5f1a7578ccc820e3f2c733a9b602e825fe661800c8b2692a72a0230",
"evidenceKind": "reused-historical-QA-not-rerun"
}
],
"dependsOn": [
"I01",
"I02",
"I03",
"I14",
"I15"
],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I29",
"title": "三项已推送修复尚未正式发行",
"priority": "P0",
"statusAtAudit": "source-fixed-not-deployed",
"impact": "正式1.25.12仍是F旧源码;目录刷新/wire截断说明/官方Claude容量没有进入正式程序。",
"nextChange": "完成首批确认修复后冻结独立发行,避免逐小修反复打包;安装再做数据保持核对。",
"acceptance": "候选源码/build/wire/UI/安装身份一一对应,再部署与正式回看;源码包不包含用户项目。",
"observations": [],
"references": [
{
"path": "docs/QA-ROLE-ROUTING-F.md",
"sha256": "a7fd3e08e44d92a4b0f71474639c63ed9578b0f9c57364e06f20ba0b43c50b05",
"evidenceKind": "reused-historical-QA-not-rerun"
},
{
"path": "docs/QA-NEWAPI-COMPATIBILITY-REVIEW.md",
"sha256": "db859bfb8ce8751dda8766037b8bbf153fa7fceb6beb581bc5899ab0f8f4326d",
"evidenceKind": "reused-historical-QA-not-rerun"
},
{
"path": "docs/QA-CLAUDE-OFFICIAL-CAPACITY.md",
"sha256": "7d0c2036a5f1a7578ccc820e3f2c733a9b602e825fe661800c8b2692a72a0230",
"evidenceKind": "reused-historical-QA-not-rerun"
}
],
"dependsOn": [
"I01",
"I02",
"I03",
"I05",
"I06",
"I07",
"I08"
],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I30",
"title": "当前规划/能力文档入口停留D/E旧时点",
"priority": "P1",
"statusAtAudit": "confirmed-documentation-drift",
"impact": "F已交付却仍有当前页说未实现,读者难判断源码和部署状态。",
"nextChange": "本轮统一当前指针,保留日期明确的历史,不把规划等于完成。",
"acceptance": "AGENTS/CAPABILITIES/NEXT-STEPS/PRODUCT-PLAN/RESEARCH-ROADMAP当前入口一致可点击。",
"observations": [],
"references": [],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": true,
"statusAfterAudit": "current-entry-pointers-corrected-documents-only"
},
{
"id": "I31",
"title": "跨产品原生导出/入站委托服务缺项",
"priority": "P2",
"statusAtAudit": "not-implemented",
"impact": "Mnemo目前只有来源包只读核对与反馈;没有运行中的导出/委托/撤销闭环。",
"nextChange": "按实际双方契约实现原字节导出、单Run/多Run归属与委托状态,不自动继承用户授权。",
"acceptance": "双方合成原件和独立真实服务验证;失败、容量缺项、撤销和旧原件完整。",
"observations": [],
"references": [
{
"path": "docs/THREE-SYSTEM-INTERFACE-FEEDBACK-2026-11-06.md",
"sha256": "ebfd0fdf5242bdcfb07282001107f41c74c984b0cef2117b1a2bb0fd79bcf1fc",
"evidenceKind": "reused-historical-QA-not-rerun"
}
],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I32",
"title": "新物理手机完整流程未验收",
"priority": "P2",
"statusAtAudit": "unverified-real-device",
"impact": "已有Companion实现与本地契约验收不能代替当前真实手机端到端。",
"nextChange": "独立配对/查看/选择权限/批准/停止/断线/撤销真实设备样本。",
"acceptance": "保存设备/宿主/浏览器版本和实际动作,无任务或凭据跨错归属。",
"observations": [],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/core/companion/device-registry.mjs",
"line": 12,
"sha256": "2fe69e47a7acf303dfcf33697b667bae9ea53c7cd17e6830f9c607a7f0222537",
"match": "export class DeviceRegistry {"
}
],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I33",
"title": "Companion操作账本达到2000后拒绝",
"priority": "P1",
"statusAtAudit": "source-confirmed-execution-cap-not-live-triggered",
"impact": "累计操作达到2000后手机操作409,并非开放模式动态账本。",
"nextChange": "分页持久化幂等操作,移除固定总数拒绝和load格式上界,不丢旧记录。",
"acceptance": "跨2000边界继续操作,幂等/unknown/断线恢复与原行保持。",
"observations": [],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/core/companion/device-registry.mjs",
"line": 124,
"sha256": "2fe69e47a7acf303dfcf33697b667bae9ea53c7cd17e6830f9c607a7f0222537",
"match": " if (Object.keys(state.operations).length >= 2000) throw companionError('手机操作账本达到上限,请在电脑处理。', 409);"
}
],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I34",
"title": "全球官方与代理真实兼容没有完整证明",
"priority": "P1",
"statusAtAudit": "unverified-beyond-recorded-samples",
"impact": "AD/AE有DeepSeek实际成功,也有Claude400/目录断连;不能据此宣称全球全部可用。",
"nextChange": "按正式新版本另冻官方优先的供应商样本与代理样本;旧样本不重写/续跑。",
"acceptance": "每连接发现/参数/流式/工具/媒体/usage/错误/真实工程独立分项,未知保留。",
"observations": [],
"references": [
{
"path": "docs/QA-LIVE-VALIDATION-AD.md",
"sha256": "bbaf225418099a9fcda31f33de8911ab727f0a359d40290758bbf2534ad4b29e",
"evidenceKind": "reused-historical-QA-not-rerun"
},
{
"path": "docs/QA-LIVE-ENGINEERING-AE.md",
"sha256": "cbf0372c0dcebce0d9b6ffe6c5536c504993cbb191cc6cd0058172e765fc99d1",
"evidenceKind": "reused-historical-QA-not-rerun"
}
],
"dependsOn": [
"I28",
"I29"
],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I35",
"title": "重复读取/缓存/经验/角色普遍收益未证明",
"priority": "P1",
"statusAtAudit": "unverified-benefit",
"impact": "D/E/F机制已部署,单例缓存与工具事实不证明广泛因果收益。",
"nextChange": "分别定义同题基线/干预、稳定线路/模型/权限、真实raw用量与质量指标。",
"acceptance": "成功率、重复读取、cache read/write、tokens/时延和失败原因同时报告;不得以提醒触发当业务完成。",
"observations": [],
"references": [
{
"path": "docs/QA-REMINDER-READBACK-D.md",
"sha256": "07282464b38040154c754a44bf12597cea74419fba257a69c341f09186c2efbf",
"evidenceKind": "reused-historical-QA-not-rerun"
},
{
"path": "docs/QA-EXPERIENCE-DRAFTS-E.md",
"sha256": "157bf3a83fcb3ec78d4f6ccbb55e4f2cc6d1ac8407fb504e06dedd4b6009d530",
"evidenceKind": "reused-historical-QA-not-rerun"
},
{
"path": "docs/QA-ROLE-ROUTING-F.md",
"sha256": "a7fd3e08e44d92a4b0f71474639c63ed9578b0f9c57364e06f20ba0b43c50b05",
"evidenceKind": "reused-historical-QA-not-rerun"
}
],
"dependsOn": [
"I09",
"I10",
"I11",
"I12",
"I24",
"I25",
"I34"
],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I36",
"title": "Purge AB/BA收益仍unknown",
"priority": "P1",
"statusAtAudit": "unverified-benefit-network-confounded",
"impact": "AG四组只有ba-off自主完成,其余三个ETIMEDOUT/unknown,不能做收益比较。",
"nextChange": "供应商兼容与基线真实交付稳定后,新冻结原版Purge AB/BA,身份和输入严格固定。",
"acceptance": "插件确实加载/边界触发/对照可比/工程质量及reported和unknown单列;旧AG失败原样保留。",
"observations": [],
"references": [
{
"path": "docs/QA-LIVE-PURGE-AG.md",
"sha256": "9bddff27433f9948dffa337c67814287a2b1282602c62e8846daea18bf4457c4",
"evidenceKind": "reused-historical-QA-not-rerun"
}
],
"dependsOn": [
"I34",
"I35"
],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I37",
"title": "批处理/后台会话/文件与其他模型资源API缺项",
"priority": "P2",
"statusAtAudit": "not-implemented-as-complete-workflow",
"impact": "原生字段能部分转交不等于支持异步任务轮询/取消、批次/文件/向量/音视频图像资源全生命周期。",
"nextChange": "按工程优先级通过供应商适配器逐类扩展,显示实际已实现能力;无需复制网关账户/计费后台。",
"acceptance": "资源创建/使用/检索/取消/清理、返回状态/工件与费用来源可核对,异步响应不误当工具完成。",
"observations": [],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/shared/contracts/model-capabilities.mjs",
"line": 1,
"sha256": "a71775c388d1afc5dfc9057528502882361694c6d9fb541e6f55257d0ca5686a",
"match": "export const MODEL_PROTOCOLS = ['chat-completions', 'responses', 'anthropic-messages'];"
},
{
"path": "src/core/models/protocols.mjs",
"line": 12,
"sha256": "0437d536c49d05651928a705bb6d92d5c76c6e1ce9f1a39121a6273cac873b27",
"match": "export { protocolRoute } from '../../shared/contracts/model-endpoint.mjs';"
}
],
"dependsOn": [
"I14",
"I15",
"I18",
"I20"
],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
},
{
"id": "I38",
"title": "加密凭据元数据超过101项被整体拒加载",
"priority": "P1",
"statusAtAudit": "confirmed-load-count-cap",
"impact": "102项保存登记会标记unavailable,开放连接数与本机保存加载范围不一致;原metadata不删除。",
"nextChange": "按版本/逐记录有效性和分页加载凭据登记,移除固定连接总数格式门槛。",
"acceptance": "102以上自有合成/加密测试登记保存重启恢复;无旧条目损失、无真实Key访问,来源绑定仍可核对。",
"observations": [
"O21"
],
"references": [
{
"path": "src/core/models/credential-vault.mjs",
"line": 20,
"sha256": "35420ba01e5ce49c8d5af6d63a51128701de80a7958d38132816c304f5895b63",
"match": " this.blocked = !state || state.schema !== 1 || !Number.isSafeInteger(state.revision) || !state.entries || typeof state.entries !== 'object' || Array.isArray(state.entries) || Object.keys(state.entries).length > 101;"
}
],
"dependsOn": [],
"fixedInThisAudit": false
}
],
"issueCounts": {
"total": 38,
"priority": {
"P0": 8,
"P1": 25,
"P2": 5
},
"documentsCorrectedHere": [
"I30"
],
"allOtherItemsRemainOpenOrUnverified": true
},
"historicalOutcomes": [
{
"sample": "W",
"qa": {
"path": "docs/QA-LIVE-DELIVERY-W.md",
"sha256": "447b6425f947b99b7e50f6b99d69c3d114a8c9fd697d05fbe93b1a1f92e4e69c",
"evidenceKind": "reused-historical-QA-not-rerun"
},
"requests": 6,
"reportedTokens": 71044,
"outcome": "matched identity; reads only; no_progress; no proposal or delivery; outlier-v2 exclusion boundary not reached"
},
{
"sample": "AD",
"qa": {
"path": "docs/QA-LIVE-VALIDATION-AD.md",
"sha256": "bbaf225418099a9fcda31f33de8911ab727f0a359d40290758bbf2534ad4b29e",
"evidenceKind": "reused-historical-QA-not-rerun"
},
"requests": 21,
"reportedTokens": 199250,
"unknownRequests": 2,
"outcome": "10 prechecks 8 pass; two Claude missing max_tokens400; DeepSeek Node11 requests autonomous9tests/build/Git passed"
},
{
"sample": "AE",
"qa": {
"path": "docs/QA-LIVE-ENGINEERING-AE.md",
"sha256": "cbf0372c0dcebce0d9b6ffe6c5536c504993cbb191cc6cd0058172e765fc99d1",
"evidenceKind": "reused-historical-QA-not-rerun"
},
"requests": 20,
"reportedTokens": 367365,
"unknownRequests": 0,
"outcome": "React and Python delivered autonomously; original pytest/terminal-report gaps preserved and later separately repaired"
},
{
"sample": "AG",
"qa": {
"path": "docs/QA-LIVE-PURGE-AG.md",
"sha256": "9bddff27433f9948dffa337c67814287a2b1282602c62e8846daea18bf4457c4",
"evidenceKind": "reused-historical-QA-not-rerun"
},
"requests": 11,
"reportedTokens": 109888,
"unknownRequests": 3,
"outcome": "ba-off delivered; ab-off/ab-on/ba-on connect ETIMEDOUT; original Purge loaded in on groups; benefit unknown"
}
],
"preservedConstraints": [
"unrestricted/full/passthrough defaults and selected user policy",
"complete historical raw/evidence",
"unknown usage not imputed",
"original network failures",
"repeated-read observations",
"Purge benefit unknown",
"source package excludes user project data"
]
}